Singing in Turrell’s Skyspace

1st Aug 2014

On Monday the 28th of August I met up with choir leader Pip Wright who leads two choirs in Penzance: Levow an Bys, ‘World Voices’ in Cornish, and The Lime Tree Dawn Chorus, a morning choir who meet at Tremenheere Sculpture Gardens  in Gulval, near Penzance.

James Turrell’s Skyspace sculpture resides within the gardens and since I first sat down and hummed in there, last May, I have been excited about its potential for choral performances. The acoustic in there is absolutely delicious; bright yet simultaneously dry and reverberant. Singing inside Turrell’s Skyspace is like singing inside a short, fat convex vase with its wide middle and narrow opening at the top. There is a seating ledge all around the sculpture’s interior and as you sing the sound fills the space before floating up where it thins, becoming focused and pure, before leaving through the Skyspace as a whisper of its former tonal self.

Pip and I had planned sing in the Skyspace to test and record the acoustic, but we hadn’t counted on being accompanied by several visitors, two young families, and a dog, all sheltering from the rain outside – and inside – as they clung to the sides of the sculpture to avoid the steady stream of rain pouring through the Skyspace hole where it lay, forming a puddle, in the middle of the floor. Much to their amusement, we went ahead and sang anyway, first tentatively and then with more clarity.

Turrell's Skyspace at Tremenheere Sculpture Gardens Turrell's Skyspace at Tremenheere Sculpture Gardens

Later, Pip moved outside the sculpture, where you can walk up a slope, becoming level with the Skyspace hole. “Can you hear me?” I shouted, and then sang. Nothing. I asked the visitors inside if they might be willing to sing, or shout, whilst I joined Pip outside. A couple of children shouted “yes!” and I ran outside to catch their sound.

After a couple of minutes, Pip and I were still waiting, with disappointment. I had hoped that if a choir performance did take place in the Skyspace, our audience could listen from outside as the sound drifted up and out through the Skyspace hole. But eventually we did hear a long, lone, ‘ah’ from a beautiful tenor voice. On returning to the the sculpture we asked who the singer was and Paul came forward.

Turrell's Skyspace at Tremenheere Sculpture Gardens

Paul is a piano teacher who hasn’t sung in years since surgery damaged his vocal chords. “I feel such disappointment with my voice now, compared to what it was”, he said. “I rarely sing anymore”. “But you sing beautifully”, both Pip and I responded. We entered into dialogue with Paul and he told us about his PhD research and expressed his concerns about his singing voice. “Your voice is beautiful now”, I said. “Leave the comparison of ‘then’ and accept your voice for what it is now”. We recommended that Paul joined a choir and Pip invited him to the Dawn Chorus the following Thursday.

Eventually the rain stopped and as the visitors started to leave, Paul, Pip and I continued to talk and then started to sing. I felt honoured that someone who felt disappointed with their vocal ability was comfortable singing with two strangers in the Skyspace sculpture on this rainy day. After ten minutes of improvised tonal sounds Paul quietly stood up and left. I lay down, looked up at the Skyspace, and Pip and I continued to sing. I am not a religious person – and I am resisting the urge to slap myself as I say this – but what I experienced felt primitive, spiritual and connected.

Pip enters Turrell's Skyspace
The entrance to Turrell's Skyspace
James Turrell's Skyspace
The Skyspace
Pip Wright
Family's shelter from the rain
A dog shelter's from the rain
Pip Wright
Emily relaxing
Paul in the Sculpture Gardens, St Michael's Mount in the distance


Later on in the week I received an email from Pip: “guess what? Our friend Paul showed up for Dawn Chorus this morning. Half way through the session he walked up and said “shall I teach my arrangement of ‘Steal Away’?” and a good moment was had by all”.


If you ever do visit the Skyspace at Tremenheere Sculpture Gardens, lie down and sing whilst looking at the Skyspace above. Go on, give it a go. You might feel silly but you also might also be surprised at how it makes you feel.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *